Friday, February 11, 2011
Thursday, February 10, 2011
DBQ - The Terror During the French Revolution
Discuss the advantages and the disadvantages of the Terror as an instrument of
the French Revolution.
During the time from 1793 to 1794, mayhem was occurring in Frnace. Prussian and Austrian troops were pushing back French armies, and the British navy was threatening the coasts of France. A war of secession was occurring in western France by social groups which included the peasantry. The Terror was a an event that altered France drastically. Anyone who was against the Jacobins was considered to be against the revolution, and they were therefore killed. Methods of killings were usually the guillotine or being shot or drowned. The street where the guillotine was became red from blood. The economy was left in a disastrous condition. The Terror from 1793 to 1794 had the advantages of making the people of France brave in any moment of action, but the number of deaths, the economic decline, and the fact that innocent people were killed did not make the Terror a justified course of action.
According to William Pitt, a British Prime Minister, the “the spirit of a people called forth by the impulse which acts so strongly in such a situation, may have the effect to make them brave in the moment of action” (doc. 8). Pitt is saying that because the Jacobin people who were for the Revolution acted quickly, that made them braver and stronger in order to face anything that would come their way.
People that were for the revolution and supporting the Jacobins believed that “the tribunals act well, that they acquit the innocent and punish the guilty,” which is made known to the government in a report on public opinion (doc 9). However, there were still people who were negatively affected by the Terror that were raising their complaints to the government as well. Complaints were repeated numerous times about the “arrest and imprisonment of citizens who are good patriots and are victims of ambition, cupidity, jealousy, and, in short, every human passion (doc. 10). To those for the Revolution, the Terror was seen as a way of being strong and standing for what one believes in. For those against the Terror; however, they believed that imprisonment of good patriotic citizens was not justified.
Areas with over 496 executions (doc 1). Over 14,000 people dead (doc 2). The terror resulted in a bloodshed, even leaving the roads red because of blood. In all of France, there were over 13,000 geographical incidences of principal indictments that lead to executions during the terror (doc 3). Camille Desmoulins, journalist and former ally of Robespierre, believed that the Terror was an pitiful way to create an area with one mindset. Desmoulins says, ““You want to remove all your enemies by means of the guillotine? Has there ever been such great folly?” (doc 6.) He wants to know if the people facing the guillotine, the women, old men, weaklings, are really dangerous? Charles James Fox finds it to be a “pity” that the French people are governed by those “who are guilty of such unheard of crimes and cruelties” (doc. 4). Who know what extreme measures the rulers of France will take in order to have everyone agree with them? The Terror proved that the French rulers will do whatever they can, by any means, to have the people agree with them. The lives of those they rule do not matter to them.
In a speech to the Nation Convention, Maximillien Robespierre says, “The revolutionary
government has to summon extraordinary activity to its aid precisely because it is at war” (doc 7). Robespierre believes that a revolutionary government’s goal is to defend the state “against the factions that assail it from every quarter” (doc. 7). Robespierre believes that because France is at war, anything can be done to the people. In reports to the government from the public, they completely disagree. If the Revolution is to make state better for the people, and the people are disagreeing with the Terror, then the Terror should not be seen as a good thing. The public said when seeing peasants on the scaffold, “What, have these wretches allowed themselves to be corrupted? If they were nobles or rich people it would not be strange, their being counter-revolutionists, but in that class we should expect all to be patriots” (doc 12). These people, who were for the Revolution, thought that it was normal to see nobles or rich people tied up, which allows one to think that cruelty is common in France. What person would want to live in a state where anyone can be on the scaffold?
The Terror during the French Revolution was ultimately a failure. It left thousands dead and many in fear. True, some Frenchmen could be braver because of the Terror, but the devastations it left France made the government out to be weak. The economic situation in France was terrible after the Terror. The complete disarray that France was in after the Terror proved that it did not better the conditions of France; rather, it made them much worse. The Terror proved that some people could take a stand in France, but their course of action was not justified in the deaths of thousands of innocent people.
Sunday, February 6, 2011
Candide Outline - Pangloss's Optimism or Martin's Pessimism?
Which do you prefer: Pangloss's optimism or Martin's pessimism? Why?
I. Although it takes strength and faith to be optimistic like Pangloss in Volataire's Candide, Pangloss's optimism is an example of satire and lacks reason because his belief is merely based on religion, however; Martin's pessimistic view prepares one for the challenges and unexpected occurrences in life, which Candide faces many of.
- Voltaire uses satire and mockery in this book to easily point out believable details and those which one could not fathom to be true, and he displays to the reader how optimistic and pessimistic views can influence someone, both positively and negatively.
- The contrast in ideas between Martin and Pangloss causes the reader to choose which character is more realistic, which character supports his ideas better, and which character is more creditable.
- Pangloss's optimism is truly satirical and leads Candide to have a false impression on the world and life events, and his optimism is a parody for Gottfried Leibniz, who questions why bad things happen to good people.
- Pangloss's optimism has brought Candide to believe that the world should be full of rape, enslavement, and war because these are events that occur in his life, and if this world is the best of all possible worlds, then these events are the best events that could happen.
- Candide is influenced in a way such that everything he does is the best thing that could happen and is what should be done, despite it being murder, such as his murdering of Don Issachar and the Grand Inquisitor and putting a sword through the innocent baron, Cunégonde's brother.
- Candide befriends Martin when he is traveling, and Martin is a cynical scholar whose pessimistic view on life is based upon hardships that have happened in his life experiences.
- Martin has more knowledge than both Pangloss and Candide, and he is also more intellectual, therefore his ideas are more substantial.
- Martin is one of the characters that can be most easily identified with because he has a more realistic outlook on life based on real life experiences. He is honest and looks at situations as they really are at face value, instead of trying to make everything seem good. He uses his experiences to shape his thinking.
- The optimism of Pangloss is the utmost satirical detail in this book, while the pessimism of Martin is the most believable detail, and he is the most believable character.
- It highly unlikely for someone to remain as optimistic as Pangloss when they have been almost hanged, infected with syphilis, and imprisoned, therefore Pangloss does not seem like a real character whose philosophy on life one could agree with or study.
- Candide is a satire, therefore Voltaire himself thinks that Pangloss's optimism is ludicrous because it is being made fun of and mocked in this book.
- It is difficult for one to take Pangloss's optimism seriously when it is being exaggerated to the point where Pangloss remains optimistic by ignoring any evidence that could possibly contradict his thoughts.
- Candide is completely influenced by outside opinions, and being influenced by Pangloss means that he believes everything in life is good and nothing can go wrong. He believes that every decision he makes, whether it is truly good or bad, is good because it is happening is he best of all possible worlds.
- Because Voltaire does not take Pangloss and his beliefs seriously and mocks them means that readers are not suppose to take Pangloss's optimism seriously; they are guided more towards taking Martin seriously because he is not being mocked to the extent that Pangloss is.
Thursday, January 27, 2011
Peter the Great and Catherine the Great Free Response Essay
Analyze the methods and degrees of success of Russian political and social reform
from the period of Peter the Great (1689–1725) through Catherine the Great
(1762–1796).
I. The degrees of success of Russian political and social reform from the period of Peter the Great through Catherine the Great were equally comparable, with Russia being expanded and wars being won, and both had downfalls, such as the peasantry being in a distressing state; but Peter the Great’s desire to make Russia into a European power did not happen until Catherine the Great came to power, therefore making her reign more successful.
II. Peter’s achievements: learned tactics and strategies but never carried them out, had the tools but didn’t pursue enough, gained knowledge of Western Europe industrial techniques and state administration, established schools, replaced church patriarchy
III. Catherine’s achievement: loved by the people, increase central control over provinces, skilled as a diplomat, Russia’s influence in European affairs increased, patron of arts
IV. Catherine and Peter’s downfalls: Peter did not fully make Russia to what he wanted, both left the peasantry distressed, Catherine reversed liberal forms, Peter made others think he was the antichrist
V. Conclusion and summary of both reigns
---------------------------------------------------
Up until the time of the rule of Peter the Great, Russia was a country that kept to itself and was not involved with Europe or European affairs. Russia was not up to par with the technology and advancements that where taking place in the rest of Europe. When Peter the Great came to power; however, his goal was to make Russia into a European power, expanding its rule and advancing its knowledge. When Catherine the Great became Empress, her goal was similar, which was to expand on Peter the Great’s ideas and to further Russia into a prosperous power. The degrees of success of Russian political and social reform from the period of Peter the Great through Catherine the Great were equally comparable, with events such as Russia being expanded and wars being won, and both had downfalls, such as the peasantry being in a distressing state; but Peter the Great’s desire to make Russia into a European power did not happen until Catherine the Great came to power, therefore making her reign more successful.
Peter the Great’s main goal in ruling Russia was to make it into a European power. Many achievements were reached when Peter was head of Russia. When he was growing up, he gained knowledge of things such as Western Europe industrial techniques and state administration. In attempts to make Russia a solidified power, Peter made reforms such as establishing schools, replacing church patriarchy, simplifying the alphabet, and so on. Peter studied and had the tools to make Russia into a ruling power, but he ultimately did not do enough to make it reach the standards that he had hoped for. Peter the Great got the reform of Russia rolling, but he was not able to carry through his hopes and imaginings.
Catherine the Great reigned from 1762 to 1796 in Russia. She was the most sovereign rule in Russia. Catherine was a loved ruled; she was loved by the Russian people. Catherine reached achievements such as increasing central control over provinces and increasing Russia’s influence in European affairs. Catherine was skilled as a diplomat and was a patron of the arts. Catherine built and founded a museum, commissioned buildings all over Russia, and did other things such as corresponding with French Encyclopedists. Catherine was able to make Russia into a ruling power, something that Peter the Great wanted to do, but did not succeed in doing. She was thought to be, by others, the most superior ruler in Russia. Catherine improved academies, journals, and libraries. Catherine the Great’s reign was truly one of huge success.
While Catherine and Peter had successful reigns in Russia, both had some downfalls. Peter wanted to make Russia a supreme ruling power in Europe. During his reign and during his life time, he did not achieve that goal. He had studied and learned way to make this happen, but it ultimately did not. The public began to think that Peter the Great was the antichrist because he introduced many reforms and restrictions. He was not as loved by the people as was Catherine. Catherine also had a few downfalls in her reign, such as reversing liberal reforms. Both rulers left the peasantry distressed, which was a major downfall in each other their reigns.
Peter the Great began the idea of making Russia into a ruling power in Europe. During his reign, he did not succeed. He failed at his ultimate goal, making Russia at the top. Catherine the Great, however; brought Russia to a higher status and allowed it to fully prosper. Catherine the Great’s reign overall was more successful because she reached the goal that Peter the Great had aimed for, but ultimately did not achieve. Both reigns were noteworthy, but Catherine the Great’s reign proved to be more successful.
Friday, January 21, 2011
Exam - DBQ
Analyze the concerns and goals of participants in the Pilgrimage of Grace and of those who opposed the movements.
o The participants of the Pilgrimage of Grace were concerned with getting back what was taken away from them, and their goal was to get rid of all evil people implementing policies that the public were opposed to, mainly Cromwell, while the ones opposed to the Pilgrimage, such as Henry VIII, believed that it might have ruined the country and was not necessary.
o Many monasteries
o Rulers did not defend the country, so participants relied on faith and the ability to help one another out
o Wanted Cromwell gone
o Leeche said it could have been prevented
In 1543, the Act of Supremacy was passed, making Henry VIII the head of the Anglican Church. This marked the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. Thomas Cromwell then implemented a series of government policies. These policies included new taxes, the expansion of royal power in the north of England, the dissolution of monasteries, and the confiscation of Catholic church lands. The Pilgrimage of Grace occurred because of these new policies. Marchers protested and demonstrated why they were right and Oliver Cromwell was wrong. The Pilgrimage of Grace occurred from October 1536 to February 1537. The participants of the Pilgrimage of Grace were concerned with getting back what was taken away from them, and their goal was to get rid of all evil people implementing policies that the public were opposed to, mainly Cromwell, while the ones opposed to the Pilgrimage, such as Henry VIII, believed that it might have ruined the country and was not necessary.
People participated in the Pilgrimage of Grace only for their “love of God, for the Holy Catholic Church militant, for the preservation of the king and his heirs, for the purification of the nobility, and to expel all evil counselors” (doc. 1). The participants had to rely on “charity, faith, poverty, and pity” (doc.2). They had to be able to help one another out if they were to be robbed or invaded. They told their “most Sovereign king” that they wanted certain heresies destroyed, the Supreme head of the Church to be the pope, the monasteries’ things returned to them, and to have Oliver Cromwell punished (doc. 5). The list continues, but the main goal of the participants of the Pilgrimage of Grace was to restore their country as it was before policies were implemented by Oliver Cromwell. Participants were angry with the fact that the Parliament spoke, not only of the King’s thoughts, but of Cromwell’s as well (doc. 6). They believed that Cromwell had too much power and should not exceed the power of that of the King.
Monks were particularly unhappy with the policies put in place by Oliver Cromwell because they took away monks’ properties. Catholic monks proposed a ballad that read, “Great God’s fame, does the Church proclaim, now to be lame, and held in bonds. Robbed, spoiled and shorn of cattle and corn, houses and lands” (doc. 4). The monasteries were robbed of their houses and land, and they participated in the Pilgrimage of Grace to try to gain all of that back. In a re-creation of a banner by marchers, the “Wounds of Christ” were depicted. It was blood dripping from a central heart, with blood also dripping from hands and feet. On the outside of this were a chalice, a plow, and a cattle horn (doc. 3). This banner symbolized the monks. The monks were the ones suffering because they had had pretty much everything taken away from them. Another person who was unhappy with what was going on was Robert Aske. Shorty before his execution, he gave a testimony, and he said that any money now being earned from abbey lands are going directly to the King. Strangers and beggars have no help on the roads (doc. 11). Aske is basically saying that everything now became based around the King, and the monasteries were not around to be of help. Things such as sea walls, dikes, and bridges that were once maintained by the monasteries were not anymore because the monks were now protesting. Monasteries were not out to help others, they were out for themselves, but they needed their land and houses in order to serve the good of the people.
Nicholas Leeche believed that this rebellion could have been stopped. He said that “the gentleman could have stopped the rebellion then, but did not, never believing their actions to be offensive to the King” (doc. 8) He is saying that the actions of Cromwell and his men were offensive to the King because of all the trouble and turmoil their new policies stirred up. Leeche believed the rebellion could have been prevented if the leaders had had any idea that this much controversy would occur. Henry VIII said to the marchers that the rebellion they committed might have ruined their country (doc. 9). The marchers gave comfort to the Scots, who were their enemies. The King was, however, sorry for what had come about from the policies, but he was very much opposed to the pilgrimage. Trials occurred for the marchers in the Pilgrimage of Grance. Many commoners were convicted in the first treason trials of participants that occurred from January to March in 1537. A total number of 144 people were convicted, 110 of them being commoners (doc. 10).
A writer hired by Thomas Cromwell said that “when every many rules, who shall obey?” (doc. 7). He said that those of lesser importance or of a lesser role and society need to comply with the fact that those with more power are going to rule over them. The marchers and participants of the Pilgrimage of Grace did not see it this way. They believed they should not have everything taken away from them, especially by someone who is not even the king. The participants had every right to protest what was going on, and if their protesting ruined their country, then Cromwell should have thought about that before implementing new government policies.
Exam - Free Response 2
Free Response #2: Discuss the political and social consequences of the Protestant Reformation in the first half of the sixteen century.
o The political and social consequences of the Protestant Reformation in the first half of the sixteenth century were evident in the persecution for going against the Catholic Church, debate about religion and splitting of states because of religious view, and having ruling power depending on whether one was Protestant or Catholic.
o Martin Luther began the Protestant Reformation by posting his 95 Theses on the door of the Wittenberg Cathedral. He was going against the sale of indulgences that the Pope had put into place.
o Separation of states occurred because of the religious views. Places became Anabaptist, Lutheran, Calvinist, and some places remained Catholic. England stayed mostly Catholic.
o Political consequences were major; monarchs became concerned in whether their country was Protestant or Catholic, depending on what religion they were. Mary I of England was called “Bloody Mary” because she killed all those who were not Catholic. War broke occurred between the Protestants and the Catholics, with the Catholics winning the first two phases, and the Protestants winning the next. Four phases took place. Politcal consequences pushed on even further than the sixteenth century when Louis XIV had many Protestants leave his country.
The Protestant Reformation took place in the sixteenth century. Much of it began when Henry VIII issued the Act of Supremacy. The Protestant Reformation caused a disconnection in Europe because people chose whether or not to be Protestant or Catholic. The political and social consequences of the Protestant Reformation in the first half of the sixteenth century were evident in the persecution for going against the Catholic Church, debate about religion and splitting of states because of religious view, and having ruling power depending on whether one was Protestant or Catholic.
Henry VIII issued the Act of Supremacy to make himself head of the Catholic Church. Martin Luther was a Catholic monk who was opposed the Pope’s selling of indulges. To explain why he was against this selling and how it went against his faith, posted his 95 Theses. He posted the 95 Theses on October 31 on the Wittenberg Cathedral. This created much controversy and conflict. Luther was not accepted by the Catholic Church anymore after going against it in such a public way. Martin Luther was persecuted for his beliefs, but he took his ideas and turned them into a new religion for people to follow. He created Lutheranism. Martin Luther created consequences for the Church, but he allowed the public to choose whether or not they agreed with Catholic views or with his.
During the sixteenth century, many people were Roman Catholic and believed in the Catholic views, faith, and beliefs. When the Protestant Reformation came about, separation of states occurred because of the religious views. Places became Anabaptist, Lutheran, Calvinist, and some places remained Catholic. England was one place that stayed mostly Catholic. These religions had very different views, some of these ideas being that Anabaptists believed in complete separation from Church and state and Calvinist believed in predestination. States were not longer united because they were separated by their religion.
Political consequences were very evident from the Protestant Reformation. Monarchs in Europe became concerned in whether their country was Protestant or Catholic, depending on what religion they were. Mary I of England is an example of someone who took it into their own hands to turn a country back into the religion of their choice. Mary I of England was called “Bloody Mary” because she killed all those who were not Catholic. Hundreds were burned at the stake in just a short amount of time. The Thiry Years’ War developed; a war occurring between the Protestants and the Catholics, with the Catholics winning the first two phases, and the Protestants winning the next. Four total phases took place. Political consequences from the Protestant Reformation had such a big impact on European states that they pushed on even further than the sixteenth century when Louis XIV had many Protestants leave his country. Politics were greatly influenced by the Protestant Reformation.
Exam - Free Response 1
Free Response #1: Describe and analyze how overseas expansion by European states affected global trade and international relations from 1600 to 1715.
o Overseas expansion by European states affected global trade and international relations by increasing the appeal to explore, which brought in resources, money, and goods, allowing Europe to become even wealthier than it was with the implementation of taxes and trade, and giving Europe control over the areas being discovered, such as the Americas.
o Animals, spices, food was taken from Europe to Americas. Once things were taken there, America and Europe could trade with each other.
o Explorers such as Christopher Columbus and Hernando Cortez established new areas to trade and explore. Incas and Aztecs were found. Cape of Good Hope was discovered.
o Europe was able to gain wealth by taxing people in the Americas and sustaining how they lived. They could sell goods to them at a high price.
o Europe gained power, and because of the discoveries of multiple places with navigation routes mapped out, trade increased. Relations between countries came into existence because they were communicating through trade.
Overseas expansion by European states was prevalent from 1600 to 1715. With many explorers seeing the work of others take off, they became interested in doing the same and finding what they could in areas such as India, Brazil, and the North America. Specific people such as Hernando Cortez, Francisco Pizarro, and Christopher Columbus used their interest in exploring to discover new places. Overseas expansion by European states affected global trade and international relations by increasing the appeal to explore, which brought in resources, money, and goods, allowing Europe to become even wealthier than it was with the implementation of taxes and trade, and giving Europe control over the areas being discovered, such as the Americas.
Trade was able to increase when trade routes where established between Europe and the newly discovered places, such as America, the Caribbean, and India. Animals were able to be taken from Europe and put in the new world, these animals being pigs, cow, sheep, etc. Spices and food were also taken to the Americas. The Americas could also share the knowledge that it had and its resources with Europe. When the Americas were discovered, trade could begin with the colonies that were established along the eastern shore. Knowing the easiest route to America as drawn out by explorers, trade could be easier than it ever was before. Trade could increase with the number of people that went to the Americas and with the knowledge of the route to get there. By trading, Europe was gaining new resources that could expand its prosperity, power, and rule.
Explorers, such as Christopher Columbus and Hernando Cortez established new areas to trade and explore. The Incas and Aztecs were discovered by Cortez and Pizarro. The Cape of Good Hope was another trade route and place that was discovered. With these places being discovered, and Europe discovering them first, Europe gained power and control. Prince Henry the Navigator was another person who was very much in favor of exploration. Christopher Columbus, one of the main people who established the Americas, was funded by the Queen. He opened up a whole new trade route by discovering the Americas. With all of these areas being discovered, Europe was opening up a multitude of new trade routes. It also had claim on the areas because it was the one that discovered their existence.
The Americas were a major trade route for Europe. With colonies being set up, and parts of Europe claiming many parts of North America, trade could begin. Countries claimed their territory; for example Spain claimed what is known today to be Florida and the Dutch settled in what it now Canada. Europe was able to tax those people that left and moved to the colonies in the Americas. Europe could sell goods to the Americas at a high price because the people living in the colonies needed these goods to live. The trade coming from the Americas could be sold at a low cost to Europe because the makers needed money and wanted their goods to be sold. Europe was able to have a distinct hold over the Americas. It controlled what went on and how trade occurred. The Americas became a major trade route for Europe.